top of page
Collecting Pollen from Flower
bee.avif

THE BUZZ

7 Reasons Parents Should Choose Private School: The History, Science, and Economics of Educational Freedom

3 days ago
14 min read

Why private education matters, how it can save taxpayers money, and why Florida is leading the way in educational choice.


The Great Misunderstanding About Private Education

One of the most persistent misconceptions in American education is that private schools exist primarily for wealthy families, undermine public education, and divert valuable resources away from the common good.

This argument is not only historically incomplete; it frequently misunderstands the science of learning, the economics of education, and, most importantly, the children whom schools are supposed to serve.

As an educator, I find one assumption particularly troubling: the belief that a single educational model can adequately serve every child.

It cannot.


Children do not enter classrooms with identical intellectual abilities, developmental trajectories, interests, personalities, or learning needs. Some excel through traditional instruction. Others require individualized interventions. Some are gifted in mathematics but struggle with reading. Others have dyslexia, autism, ADHD, or language-processing differences. Some require acceleration, while others benefit from additional time and instruction.

A child's education should reflect those differences rather than demand conformity to a standardized system.


This is where high-quality private education provides an important alternative.

Private schools are not automatically better than public schools. Some public schools are exceptional, just as some private schools are ineffective. Nor should homeschooling or microschooling be dismissed universally.

However, a well-designed, professionally staffed private school can combine the advantages of individualized education with the academic structure, expertise, resources, and social opportunities that many smaller or home-based alternatives struggle to provide.


And contrary to the popular political narrative, private education can also produce meaningful financial savings for taxpayers.

Here are seven reasons why parents should seriously consider private education.


1. Private Schools Are Part of America's Educational Foundation, Not an Attack on It

The popular assumption that public education came first and private schools emerged later is historically incorrect.

Long before America's modern public school districts existed, education was provided through private academies, religious institutions, charitable organizations, tutors, community schools, and apprenticeships.

Historian Carl Kaestle documented this diverse educational landscape in his research on early American schooling. Education before the nineteenth-century common-school movement was far more decentralized than the system familiar to us today.

In a 2001 study published in History of Education Quarterly, historians Kim Tolley and Nancy Beadie reported that by 1850 the United States had more than 6,100 incorporated academies, with enrollments approximately nine times those of the nation's colleges.

These institutions contributed to America's intellectual development, offering subjects ranging from classical languages and mathematics to science and practical studies.

Of course, early educational systems were also characterized by serious inequalities in access. The expansion of publicly supported education addressed important deficiencies and became a major achievement of American society.

But public education's historical importance does not diminish the legitimacy of private education.

In fact, American constitutional history recognizes the importance of allowing families to choose.

In the landmark 1925 Supreme Court decision Pierce v. Society of Sisters, the Court rejected an Oregon law effectively requiring children to attend public schools rather than private institutions.

The decision affirmed an important principle: parents possess a protected liberty interest in directing their children's education.

Educational freedom is not a recent political invention. It is a longstanding feature of American educational development.

Private schools preserve the ability to experiment with different educational philosophies, including classical education, Montessori-inspired methods, STEM-intensive programs, language immersion, and other specialized approaches.

The existence of different educational models is not evidence of a broken system. It is recognition that intellectual development is diverse.

Research: Tolley & Beadie (2001); Kaestle (1972); Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925).


2. Smaller Classrooms Can Produce Meaningful Academic Advantages

Class size matters, particularly in the early years of education.

The question is not merely how many children occupy a classroom, but how much meaningful instructional attention each child receives.

One of the most influential educational experiments was Tennessee's Project STAR, which randomly assigned approximately 11,600 students to classrooms of different sizes.


Economist Alan Krueger's analysis, published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in 1999, found that students assigned to smaller classes demonstrated improved academic performance.

Subsequent research by Raj Chetty and colleagues, published in 2011, connected the experiment to long-term outcomes and found that students assigned to smaller classes were more likely to attend college.

These findings should not be interpreted as proof that every small classroom is automatically effective.


A classroom of eight students with an ineffective teacher is not necessarily preferable to a classroom of twenty with an excellent one.

But smaller classes create the conditions in which excellent teaching can become more responsive.


A teacher who knows each student's abilities can identify misconceptions earlier, adjust the pace of instruction, provide more frequent feedback, and spend more time in substantive dialogue.

These advantages are especially valuable when children are learning foundational mathematics, reading, writing, and reasoning.

In a large institutional setting, differentiation may be an aspiration. In a deliberately small classroom, it can become part of everyday practice.

The goal is not simply fewer students. It is more meaningful education per student.


Parents considering private schools should examine actual class sizes, student-teacher interactions, and the methods used to individualize instruction rather than relying on advertised ratios alone.

Research: Krueger (1999); Chetty et al. (2011).


3. Different Learners Require Different Educational Environments

Perhaps the most important argument for educational choice concerns the extraordinary diversity of human learning.

Our education system routinely groups children according to chronological age. Yet children of the same age can differ substantially in language development, executive functioning, mathematical reasoning, working memory, emotional regulation, and academic readiness.


A child who struggles with decoding words may possess exceptional mathematical reasoning. A student with autism may demonstrate advanced knowledge in science while finding crowded, unpredictable classrooms overwhelming. A gifted reader may require acceleration while simultaneously needing support with writing.

These differences are not evidence of intellectual inferiority. They are reminders that learning is multidimensional.


High-quality private schools can offer a flexible educational environment through smaller classes, targeted interventions, accelerated instruction, alternative teaching approaches, and responsive scheduling.

Consider two children entering seventh grade.


One reads at a tenth-grade level but struggles with sixth-grade mathematics. Another performs advanced algebra but requires structured literacy instruction.

Both deserve educational programs that reflect their actual abilities rather than assuming that grade level determines every instructional need.

Private schools may have greater freedom to organize instruction around those individual needs.


However, parents must carefully investigate the services each school actually provides. Private schools are not uniformly equipped to serve children with disabilities, and students placed privately by their parents do not automatically retain the same individual entitlement to special education services provided under IDEA in public schools.


For some children, the services available through a public school's individualized education program may be the better option.

For others, an appropriately equipped private school may provide a more effective daily learning environment.


True educational equity does not require identical instruction. It requires giving children the support and opportunities they need to succeed.

This is why educational freedom matters.


4. A Comprehensive Private School Can Offer More Than Homeschooling or a Microschool

Homeschooling and microschooling have become increasingly popular educational alternatives, particularly among families seeking flexibility and greater control over instruction. Both can serve children successfully. But a fundamental distinction exists between a flexible learning arrangement and a comprehensive educational institution. A well-resourced private school can bring together professional educators with expertise across mathematics, literature, science, history, languages, fine arts, and technology.


Students can benefit from an integrated curriculum supported by laboratories, specialist teachers, extracurricular activities, academic assessments, and structured opportunities to collaborate with peers.

This breadth becomes increasingly important as children advance into middle and high school. Teaching elementary reading is not the same as teaching calculus. Delivering an introductory science lesson is not equivalent to providing an advanced chemistry laboratory. A general interest in history does not automatically provide the subject expertise needed to teach classical civilizations, research methods, and historical interpretation.


Parents who homeschool successfully often invest extraordinary time, financial resources, and personal effort into assembling these opportunities.

Similarly, some microschools employ exceptional educators and provide rigorous instruction. Others operate with limited specialist staffing or insufficient evidence of academic effectiveness. A 2025 RAND Corporation report examining microschools highlighted the difficulty of evaluating the sector. Researchers found substantial variation among programs and limited comparable student achievement data, making sweeping claims of success or failure unreliable.

This uncertainty matters when public education funding is involved.

Research by Chetty, Friedman, and Rockoff, published in the American Economic Review in 2014, demonstrated that teacher effectiveness can have meaningful long-term consequences for students, including college attendance and future earnings. What matters is the quality of instruction—not whether a learning environment is fashionable, unconventional, or attractively marketed.

Parents should therefore ask whether a school offers a coherent curriculum, qualified instructors, appropriate facilities, measured academic progress, and a stable educational community.


Innovation should complement educational expertise, not substitute for it.


5. Private Schools Can Deliver Strong Academic Outcomes—But Parents Should Demand Evidence

School choice debates often deteriorate into sweeping declarations that private schools outperform public schools or that public schools are inherently more accountable. Neither assertion is universally supported by the research.

Academic outcomes vary considerably among institutions, and comparisons can be misleading when family income, prior achievement, parental involvement, and student characteristics are ignored.


Nevertheless, several studies demonstrate that private-school choice programs can produce meaningful benefits. A particularly relevant example comes from Florida. In a 2019 Urban Institute analysis, Matthew Chingos, Tomás Monarrez, and Daniel Kuehn examined outcomes among students participating in Florida's Tax Credit Scholarship Program. When scholarship participants were compared with academically and demographically similar public-school students, the researchers found that:

  • 57% of scholarship participants enrolled in college, compared with 51% of their comparison-group peers.

  • Students participating in the scholarship program were more likely to enroll full time.

  • Some cohorts also demonstrated modest improvements in degree attainment.

These are encouraging findings, although matching students statistically is not equivalent to randomly assigning them to schools. The study does not establish that every participating private school caused superior outcomes.

There is also evidence that school quality differs dramatically. Research on Louisiana's private-school voucher program found negative initial achievement effects, demonstrating why parents should never confuse the label private with a guarantee of quality. The lesson is straightforward.


Good schools should measure and demonstrate student growth.

Parents should ask how schools assess literacy, mathematics, writing, scientific reasoning, and progress over time.

A school should be able to explain what happens when a student falls behind, how advanced learners are challenged, and how teachers use assessment information to improve instruction. Tests should inform instruction rather than dominate it.

The strongest educational institutions balance measurable academic achievement with curiosity, creativity, critical thinking, and genuine intellectual development.

A school's greatest advertisement should be what its students learn—not simply what its marketing department promises.

Research: Chingos, Monarrez & Kuehn (2019); Abdulkadiroğlu, Pathak & Walters (2018).


6. Private Education Can Build Stronger Relationships, Belonging, and Intellectual Communities

Education is not simply the transmission of academic information.

It is also a profoundly social process.

Students develop intellectual confidence through relationships with teachers, collaboration with peers, meaningful academic challenges, and participation in a community. A major meta-analysis published in Review of Educational Research in 2011 examined 99 studies concerning teacher-student relationships.

Researchers Debora Roorda and colleagues found that positive teacher-student relationships were associated with stronger student engagement and academic achievement. This does not prove that private schools automatically create better relationships. It does establish that the relationships schools cultivate matter.

Smaller, intentionally designed educational communities can make those connections easier to develop and sustain.


Students may have more opportunities to be known as individuals rather than simply as members of an administrative category.

A child who struggles in one subject can still be recognized for artistic talent, scientific curiosity, musical ability, leadership, or kindness.

This becomes particularly significant for children who have experienced academic frustration or social isolation. A comprehensive private school can also provide opportunities that go beyond individualized academic work: athletics, theater, music, robotics, debate, community service, and collaborative projects.

These activities are not educational luxuries. They help children practice communication, cooperation, responsibility, and belonging.

Microschools and homeschool communities can provide these experiences too, but their availability depends heavily on the program, the family's resources, and the surrounding community. The purpose of a school should be to develop capable, knowledgeable, responsible human beings—not merely students who can complete worksheets.


A successful education should give a child both intellectual independence and a meaningful place within a community.

Research: Roorda et al. (2011); Allen et al. (2018).


7. Private Education Can Save Taxpayers Money—and Florida Shows Why Educational Freedom Matters

One of the most common criticisms of private school scholarships is that they supposedly take money away from public education.

This argument often overlooks an important economic distinction:

The amount government spends to provide education is not necessarily the amount it must spend when a child attends a qualified alternative school.

When parents independently pay private-school tuition, they generally continue contributing through the taxes supporting public education while assuming the direct cost of educating their own children.

This can reduce the instructional costs public schools would otherwise incur.

When governments provide scholarships, the fiscal calculation becomes more complicated—but there is evidence that well-designed programs can save public money.


What Florida's Numbers Actually Show

According to the Florida Department of Education's official 2024–25 expenditure report, the statewide average district expenditure was approximately $11,531 per student, including state, local, and federal funding and reported district indirect costs. Meanwhile, Step Up For Students reports that Florida's private-school scholarships average approximately $8,000 for the 2026–27 school year.

Florida public-school expenditure (2024–25): $11,531 per student.

Average private-school scholarship (2026–27): approximately $8,000.

The numerical difference is approximately $3,531.

That difference illustrates why private-school scholarships can cost less than conventional public-school provision. However, it is not a direct measure of taxpayer savings. The figures cover different years and funding categories, and not every dollar of public-school spending disappears when a student transfers.

The stronger fiscal evidence comes from studies that actually evaluate government costs and savings.


Florida Has Documented Savings Before

In 2008, Florida's Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability (OPPAGA), an office of the state legislature, examined the state's corporate income tax credit scholarship program.

Its analysis estimated that during fiscal year 2007–08, the program avoided approximately $1.49 in state education expenditures for each $1 in corporate tax revenue forgone through the scholarship tax credits.

That represented a net fiscal benefit under the program's funding structure at the time. In a peer-reviewed 2018 article in Journal of School Choice, researcher Martin Lueken examined ten tax-credit scholarship programs across seven states.

Using a range of assumptions, the study estimated positive fiscal impacts ranging from approximately $1,650 to $3,000 per scholarship student through fiscal year 2014. These findings are important, although they do not establish that every modern scholarship program automatically produces savings.

Public-school districts have fixed operating costs, including buildings and certain administrative expenses. Scholarship funding also creates additional costs when recipients would otherwise have attended private schools without government support. Responsible fiscal analysis must consider both factors.

Nevertheless, the evidence refutes the categorical claim that funding private education necessarily harms taxpayers.


Educational Choice Can Also Benefit Public-School Students

There is another important finding that critics often overlook.

In a 2023 study published in the American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, economists David Figlio, Cassandra Hart, and Krzysztof Karbownik studied Florida's expanding private-school choice program.

They found that students who remained in public schools experienced modest improvements in outcomes where private-school competition was greater.

These included higher standardized test scores and reductions in absenteeism and suspension rates. The results were particularly pronounced among lower-income students. This finding challenges the assumption that educational choice must be a zero-sum contest between public and private schools.

Under the right conditions, greater competition can create incentives for improvement across institutions.


Why Florida's Educational Freedom Is So Important

Florida has become one of the country's most significant examples of expanded educational choice.

Following the passage of House Bill 1 in 2023, eligibility for major private-school scholarship programs expanded to Florida students eligible for K–12 public education, regardless of household income.

Programs include the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship and the Family Empowerment Scholarship for Educational Options, while qualifying children with disabilities may receive support through the Family Empowerment Scholarship for Students with Unique Abilities. The availability of funding remains subject to statutory requirements, program rules, and funding priorities. Educational freedom does not guarantee admission to every school or eliminate all tuition differences.

But it substantially changes the opportunities available to families.

A child should not be limited to a particular educational institution merely because of a residential address. A family's income should not be the sole determining factor in accessing an educational environment that better matches a child's needs. And children with learning differences should not have to struggle through an unsuitable educational setting simply because an alternative would otherwise be financially inaccessible.

Florida's approach provides a framework for expanding opportunity while allowing public schools, private schools, homeschooling families, and other educational models to coexist.


The purpose of educational funding should be the education of children—not the preservation of any single institutional model.


The Question We Should Really Be Asking About Education

For too long, debates over private schools have been framed as ideological struggles.

Public versus private.

Government versus parents.

Traditional schooling versus alternative education.

These debates frequently miss the central question.

What educational environment gives a particular child the best opportunity to flourish?


The answer will not be identical for every student.

I believe strong public schools are essential. I also believe strong private schools are essential. Families benefit when effective educational institutions exist in multiple forms and are accessible to children from different backgrounds.

But parents should never assume that homeschooling or a microschool is inherently superior simply because it is smaller, newer, or less institutional. Nor should they assume that a prestigious private-school name guarantees educational quality.


The strongest private schools distinguish themselves through serious academic standards, knowledgeable teachers, individualized instruction, institutional stability, and opportunities that extend far beyond a single classroom.

Private education should not merely imitate public education on a smaller scale. It should demonstrate why its educational model is worth choosing.

Likewise, policymakers should evaluate schooling according to student outcomes, equity, accountability, and responsible use of public resources rather than institutional loyalty.


Florida has taken a meaningful step by recognizing that educational opportunity should not be determined exclusively by geography or family wealth.

Now schools must meet the responsibility that accompanies that freedom.

They must prove that they can educate children effectively.

The historical case for private education is substantial. The evidence supporting smaller classes, excellent teachers, and supportive learning relationships is compelling. Research on school-choice programs demonstrates that thoughtfully designed alternatives can improve educational outcomes and, under appropriate conditions, save taxpayer money.

But the most important argument is ultimately human rather than financial.

Every child is different.

Every child deserves to be challenged.

Every child deserves to be understood.

And every child deserves the opportunity to attend a school where their abilities can develop into genuine intellectual achievement.

Educational freedom is not about abandoning public education. It is about refusing to abandon children whose needs are better served somewhere else.

That is why private education matters.

And that is why the future of American education must include meaningful choice.


Research and References

The following academic publications, government reports, and primary sources support the historical, educational, and fiscal arguments discussed above.

Historical foundations and educational freedom

1. Tolley, K., & Beadie, N. (2001). Reappraisals of the Academy Movement: Introduction. History of Education Quarterly, 41(2), 216–224.

2. Kaestle, C. F. (1972). Common Schools Before the Common School Revival: New York Schooling in the 1790s. History of Education Quarterly, 12(4), 465–500.

3. U.S. Supreme Court. (1925). Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510.

Classroom size, teachers, and student development

4. Krueger, A. B. (1999). Experimental Estimates of Education Production Functions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(2), 497–532.

5. Chetty, R., et al. (2011). How Does Your Kindergarten Classroom Affect Your Earnings? Evidence from Project STAR. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(4), 1593–1660.

6. Chetty, R., Friedman, J. N., & Rockoff, J. E. (2014). Measuring the Impacts of Teachers II: Teacher Value-Added and Student Outcomes in Adulthood. American Economic Review, 104(9), 2633–2679.

7. Roorda, D. L., et al. (2011). The Influence of Affective Teacher–Student Relationships on Students' School Engagement and Achievement. Review of Educational Research, 81(4), 493–529.

8. Allen, K., et al. (2018). What Schools Need to Know About Fostering School Belonging: A Meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review, 30, 1–34.

School choice, microschools, and academic outcomes

9. Chingos, M. M., Monarrez, T., & Kuehn, D. (2019). The Effects of the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship Program on College Enrollment and Graduation: An Update. Urban Institute.

10. Figlio, D. N., Hart, C. M. D., & Karbownik, K. (2023). Effects of Maturing Private School Choice Programs on Public School Students. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 15(4), 255–294.

11. Abdulkadiroğlu, A., Pathak, P. A., & Walters, C. R. (2018). Free to Choose: Can School Choice Reduce Student Achievement?. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(1), 175–206.

12. Covelli, L., Schweig, J., & Ohls, S. (2025). Is It Possible to Determine the Effects of the Microschool Sector on Students?. RAND Corporation.

Economics, Florida scholarships, and student rights

13. Lueken, M. F. (2018). The Fiscal Effects of Tax-Credit Scholarship Programs in the United States. Journal of School Choice.

14. Florida Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability. (2008). The Corporate Income Tax Credit Scholarship Program Saves State Dollars. Report 08-68.

15. Florida Department of Education. (2025). 2024–25 District and State Per-Pupil Expenditures.

ProfessorMattW — Commentary on education, educational philosophy, learning science, and the future of American schooling.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page